Understanding grammar can be challenging, especially when it comes to subtleties like notional concord. Notional concord, also called synesis, occurs when the verb agrees not with the grammatical form of the subject but with the sense or meaning that the subject conveys. In other words, it is a type of agreement based on the idea of what is being expressed rather than strict grammatical rules. This phenomenon is common in English, particularly when dealing with collective nouns, indefinite pronouns, or phrases that suggest a general meaning. Learning to recognize examples of notional concord can help both writers and speakers sound more natural and fluent in English.
What is Notional Concord?
Notional concord happens when a verb or pronoun aligns with the meaning or notion of the subject rather than its grammatical form. While standard grammatical rules dictate that singular subjects take singular verbs and plural subjects take plural verbs, notional concord allows for flexibility based on logic or common sense. For example, a group of people may be treated as a single entity grammatically but understood as multiple individuals in meaning. This is why we often see verbs that seem to disagree with their subjects in formal grammar but are perfectly natural in everyday usage.
Examples with Collective Nouns
One of the most common areas where notional concord occurs is with collective nouns. Collective nouns refer to a group of people or things as a single unit. Depending on whether the group is seen as a whole or as individuals, the verb may be singular or plural.
-
The team is winning the championship this year. (Singular verb – team considered as a single unit)
-
The team are arguing among themselves about the best strategy. (Plural verb – team members considered individually)
-
The committee has reached a decision. (Singular verb – committee as one body)
-
The committee have submitted their individual reports. (Plural verb – members acting separately)
Examples with Indefinite Pronouns
Indefinite pronouns like everyone, someone, and nobody can create situations where notional concord is applied. These pronouns are grammatically singular, but the verb may reflect the meaning intended by the speaker.
-
Everyone is ready for the trip. (Standard singular agreement)
-
Everyone in the group are excited about their own plans. (Plural verb emphasizes individual experiences)
-
None of the players is absent today. (Singular verb – none seen as zero or not one)
-
None of the players are missing their equipment. (Plural verb – none considered as multiple people)
Examples with Expressions of Quantity
When expressions of quantity such as a lot of, some of, or half of are used, the verb can follow the notion of what the subject represents rather than its grammatical number.
-
A lot of the cake has been eaten. (Singular verb – cake is treated as a single item)
-
A lot of the cookies are missing from the jar. (Plural verb – cookies are multiple items)
-
Half of the money was spent wisely. (Singular verb – money seen as one sum)
-
Half of the students were late to class. (Plural verb – students treated as individuals)
Examples with Titles and Names
Sometimes, titles of books, movies, organizations, or places are singular in form but represent multiple items, leading to notional concord with a plural verb.
-
The United States is a powerful nation. (Singular form – treated as one country)
-
The Beatles are one of the most influential bands in history. (Plural verb – band members implied)
-
War and Peace is considered a classic novel. (Singular verb – title of one book)
-
The Chronicles of Narnia are loved by children around the world. (Plural verb – multiple books)
Examples with Collective Ideas or Concepts
Notional concord also occurs when the subject represents an abstract idea or a group concept. The verb may follow the notion rather than the literal singular form of the noun.
-
Mathematics is difficult for many students. (Singular verb – treated as a single field of study)
-
The sciences are constantly evolving. (Plural verb – sciences treated as multiple fields)
-
Politics is often complicated. (Singular verb – politics seen as one concept)
-
The arts are essential to human culture. (Plural verb – arts considered as multiple disciplines)
Why Notional Concord is Important
Recognizing and using notional concord correctly makes writing and speech sound more natural and fluent. Strict adherence to grammatical number can sometimes make sentences awkward or misleading. For instance, referring to a sports team entirely as singular may feel impersonal when the focus is on individual players. Notional concord allows writers and speakers to reflect meaning and context more accurately, enhancing clarity and communication.
Practical Tips for Using Notional Concord
Understanding notional concord can take practice. Here are a few tips to help
-
Consider the meaning of the subject. Is it being viewed as a whole or as separate members?
-
Think about whether the sentence emphasizes individual actions or collective activity.
-
Pay attention to indefinite pronouns and expressions of quantitythey often require flexible agreement.
-
In formal writing, follow standard grammatical agreement unless notional concord improves clarity.
Notional concord is a subtle but important aspect of English grammar that reflects the logic and meaning behind a sentence rather than just its form. By understanding examples of notional concordsuch as with collective nouns, indefinite pronouns, expressions of quantity, titles, and abstract conceptswriters and speakers can produce language that feels natural, accurate, and contextually appropriate. Mastery of this concept not only improves communication but also enhances the stylistic quality of writing, making it an essential tool for anyone looking to deepen their understanding of English grammar.