Simply earlier than the beginning of the European Championships in August we’ll know the brand new president for the EHF, the European Hockey Federation. Both Peter Elders, a former umpire from The Netherlands or Marcos Hofmann, the president for Membership Junior in Spain. On August 18 we’ll know who follows within the footsteps of Marijke Fleuren (NED) as president for the EHF and subsequently member of the chief board of the FIH. Merely put, it’s a alternative between a diplomat and an entrepreneur. However lowering these males to those phrases would do them no justice, nor would it not be truthful. So let’s look past the sloganesk and discuss in depth about each choices.
We spoke with each presidential candidates within the first week of July and have launched the complete interviews as (video) podcasts on Spotify, YouTube, in addition to the same old podcast channels like Apple, Google and extra… Or you can watch these in full right here ↓🙂
Marcos Hofmann (01:19:31)
No time to take heed to this ↑ in full? Or need to know a few of my opinions on what we talked about? Learn on….
So why describe them as a diplomat and entrepreneur?
Each males are fairly completely different from one another. Though in addition they share a number of the standard superficial traits of people who performed and managed our sport for many years: white, privileged, household males…
Whereas Peter Elders, who by the best way I contemplate to be the diplomat on this comparability, is a typical product of the Dutch. When confronted with an issue the go to reflex is… let’s discuss, discover mutual grounds and attain a compromise:
We’ve been preventing the FIH for the final six or eight years. And albeit, we did by no means win a type of fights. And it has troubled our relation and I feel that’s must be one of many key gadgets. As a result of I feel Europe must be robust and a robust Europe must be a part of the FIH. To make hockey stronger on this planet. So be part of them, not combat them.
Peter Elders
Elders is a real grassroots participant till the age of 18, earlier than choosing up the whistle. Which introduced him to all main worldwide occasions, umpiring on the European Championships, World Cups and the Olympics. Earlier than turning into the volunteer board member at his membership, the EHF and the FIH. Often lively in guidelines committees.
Marcos Hofmann alternatively has a unique response. He described it himself because the bar perspective:
My perspective in life is like, as an alternative of complaining, you simply attempt to repair it. I name it the bar perspective. You see a goal, say maintain my beer and there you go…
Marcos Hofmann
On the age of 24, a fanatic participant himself, he determined to prioritise his profession in banking when the nationwide crew proved to be out of attain. When, after a while overseas, he returned to Barcelona to handle the household enterprise, he thought of a training problem. However along with his enterprise background he gravitated in the direction of administration and administration. At the moment he’s the president of Membership Junior, close to Barcelona.
The distinction in characters doesn’t imply Elders can’t be entrepreneurial, nor that Hofmann couldn’t be a diplomat when want be. Make your individual name from the interviews above. Or learn on, understanding on this column it’s concerning the combo of their solutions and my opinions. In order that’s why…
In regards to the EHF
When requested abut the explanation for existence of one thing just like the EHF each first have a considerably comparable reply. The place Hofmann compares the federations to governments stating you want completely different ranges in authorities from (inter)nationwide to regional and native. As a result of with a purpose to serve your folks, the nearer you’re to them, the higher you possibly can serve them. And Elders factors out as a result of as a gaggle we’re stronger than people. And the EHF must be the voice, the coach and the guide to its nationwide associations (NA’s).
Each agree Europe, particularly beneath its present president Marijke Fleuren, has been the entrance runner globally in gender steadiness and inclusion. Which is one thing to cherish and proceed…
Hofmann added a reality few of us knew or realised I’m certain. The truth that we’re additionally the worldwide powerhouse in organising tournaments. Europe hosts extra aggressive occasions yearly than all different continental federations, together with the FIH itself put collectively. This isn’t counting the hundreds and hundreds of official video games being performed each week by women and men between the ages of 6 and 66 (or older) in organised leagues and tournaments by the NA’s that make up the EHF. This unbelievable portfolio of tournaments managed by the EHF and its NA’s makes all can play at their degree, leisure or aggressive. And if as a rustic you might have ambitions, inside 3 to 4 years a gifted era might rise to the highest. Additionally one thing to cherish and proceed…
Elders is extra a federation man and Hofmann most likely extra membership focussed. For Elders the EHF clearly is a matter of serving the nations whereas keeping track of the golf equipment as nicely after all. Hofmann, right now nonetheless a membership president in Spain, agrees the EHF is “a membership of NA’s” however recognises the golf equipment are what differentiates Europe from the opposite continents and FIH. Half of the portfolio of the EHF occasions are membership primarily based. However he recognises maybe extra that golf equipment must be thought of extra within the challenges they face from worldwide calendars and the deal with nationwide groups.
Improvement is one thing completely different in numerous international locations
Sport and hockey have a really completely different “purpose for being” all over the world. If we exaggerate a bit you can say within the US it’s all about getting scholarships to pay for an schooling or (for different sports activities) concerning the leisure business. In Commonwealth international locations like England you can say it’s extra about simply one of many programs it’s a must to observe at school, like math, or geography,… In Asia, international locations like India or Pakistan, it’s all concerning the cash you possibly can earn. If somebody is paying, folks will play hockey. If there isn’t any cash, they won’t play. Whereas in our elements of western Europe it’s about recreation, it’s part of the schooling of our youngsters and a alternative for a wholesome way of life. It’s the place we come along with household and pals.
All sports activities directors, all around the world, will declare growth of the sport is an important merchandise on the agenda for them. However what is supposed by growth could be very completely different for them. My guess (let’s make it clear this not the view essentially of both Elders or Hofmann) is from 140 international locations affiliated to the FIH, over 100 nations are in it simply to have a NA with some folks employed, a small group of athletes that infrequently play one thing worldwide so authorities funding and IOC funding kicks in and supplies a job to the folks employed of their NA. Or it’s used as a stepping stone into their nationwide Olympic affiliation. Some 40 NA’s sincerely need to develop to variety of gamers and a few 20 have a workable lively hockey inhabitants. In Europe we’ve some 40 NA’s affiliated to the EHF. And whereas we would do higher than the numbers sketched above for the FIH, it’s not all sunshine and rainbows in Europe both. A serious problem for any sports activities governing physique in hockey is methods to develop the variety of gamers. Which for us represents true growth.
Each candidates agree focussing on rising by first rising the fanbase, as promoted by the FIH, is not going to be the highway to success. Elders thinks the answer is just not so sophisticated. For him it will be sufficient to ensure NA’s are run by folks from the hockey neighborhood to ensure their love for the sports activities does the remaining. He thinks completely different codecs of hockey have a task to play. From our conventional 11v11 over indoor hockey to 5s.
Hofmann elaborated a bit extra in his reply right here. Additionally stating hockey may by no means be the spectator sport some would love us to turn into. As a result of it’s a small ball, a giant discipline and a real crew sport, the place the crew dynamics play a much bigger function than in different “comparable” stick & ball sports activities the place it’s only one participant at a time swinging a stick on the ball. This makes it a troublesome sport to observe for the non-initiated, the final sports activities fan if you’ll. So we’ve to deal with rising the bottom of the pyramid (or Christmas tree in response to Elders). However when your numbers are so insignificant (some international locations have much less gamers than the U14 women part of the membership from Hofmann) it’s not simple. Every nation will want a tailor made strategy. Simply offering a second-hand pitch and sending over some sticks and balls is not going to actually make a distinction. Additionally pushing our personal membership mannequin on international locations with a unique tradition is not going to remedy something both. So we should always cease preaching our beliefs and fashions onto others, inside and outdoors of Europe. We must always take heed to how they need to remedy it themselves and help their plans the place attainable. Show an inexpensive pathway to the highest of our sport for the aggressive groups. The EHF already is doing excellent work with their portfolio of occasions is the opinion of Hofmann. So assist them create the infrastructure and discover the means to assist these international locations imagine sincerely they can also make it occur…
Is 5s a risk or the answer?
For me, once more not talking for any of the candidates right here, 5s is the largest risk to our sport. It’s one thing synthetic that was created within the hopes of not shedding the era with a shorter consideration span and fewer keen on a dedication. I’ve referred to as it Frankenstein’s monster earlier than as a result of I do imagine, like within the story, the monster will come again to kill it’s creator.
One of many few good concepts that had been communicated by FIH lately has been the choice to (as soon as once more) permit for hockey to be performed on any floor. If a water-based synthetic grass pitch is just not an possibility, play on pure grass, concrete, clay, no matter…
What ought to have been added for me is… Play on a full sized pitch or a smaller discipline. Play 11v11 or 8v8 or 6v6 or 3v3 or no matter… Play the sport in no matter form or type. No matter it takes from a growth standpoint to develop the variety of folks truly taking part in the game… let’s make that occur. That’s what growth is about. Nonetheless topsport is by nature elitist and advantage primarily based. And it wants constant infrastructure and algorithm to make it a degree taking part in discipline and guarantee a good competitors. So use 5s or 3v3 or no matter format you want for growth and exhibition occasions to offer folks a style of hockey. However if you make it a competing aggressive format you place our 11v11 recreation in danger. And that’s the reverse of what our federation ought to do for our sport. Anyway… that’s my view on issues.
Peter Elders says he was within the room when 5s was invented and the foundations needed to be made. Based on him it was meant to be a really versatile type to assist growth and showcase hockey in uncommon locations. When IOC nonetheless advised FIH it wished them to deliver fewer athletes to the Youth Olympic Video games it grew to become one thing greater than only a growth format. Nonetheless Elders disagrees with me and doesn’t contemplate 5s a threat. He believes, despite the fact that hockey’s Olympic future was in danger some 10 years in the past, it’s not in danger anymore. He believes our 11v11 format is safe for at the least the following 3 Olympic Video games. He additionally thinks a robust EHF may have sufficient energy inside FIH to guard our recreation.
I feel we’ve misplaced an excessive amount of affect within the FIH to make that declare…
Marcos Hofmann sees 5s a bit extra as a risk to our sport. He states hockey 5s lacks the historical past and playerbase of different brief codecs in different sports activities. Making it a aggressive format as an alternative of an exhibition and growth software, it grew to become a burden on an already crowded worldwide calendar and the NA budgets. Now the EHF has to create qualifying occasions for 5s. Whereas it might have served very nicely as an exhibition occasion such because the thrilling occasion the FIH organised within the port of Lausanne in 2022. Now there’s discuss of doing an exhibition occasion with 5s on the pyramids in Egypt. In that capability it might serve a function. Hofmann nonetheless thinks it shouldn’t be the governing our bodies that organise these sorts of occasions. He thinks they need to deal with their core duties and go away these type of occasions to industrial companions to take care of.
Based on me, the mid tier and decrease tier international locations now assume they’ve a neater path to a world cup (and who know the Video games perhaps). And this might make it simpler to get extra funds from their authorities to run their NA. Nonetheless what they fail to have in mind is, when 5s turns into a recognised format, the established tier 1 hockey nations will almost certainly take management and take their spot within the worldwide occasions once more. As a result of plain and easy, they’ve the numbers that make it loads simpler to discipline a stronger crew, ought to they select to deal with 5s as nicely.
Hofmann recognises the EHF has misplaced a number of “energy” within the FIH. However he nonetheless thinks the voice of the EHF, when push involves shove, carries a number of weight within the FIH. And it must be sufficient to stop 5s taking the place of 11v11 on the Video games.
What adjustments might be acceptable within the transfer to dry turf
The FIH has advised all involved, with out a lot concertation many add, the deadline for a non-irrigated synthetic pitch (or dry turf) would be the World cup to be hosted in Belgium and the Netherlands in the summertime of 2026. Whereas I feel there’s not a soul on this planet who doesn’t recognise the necessity for a transfer to utilizing much less (and if attainable no) water as a useful resource. The brief deadline does elevate some eyebrows.
As we converse (July 2023) there isn’t any technical answer that will permit for our recreation to be performed the identical approach as on the present water-based synthetic grass pitches. Polytan, the turf producer partnered to FIH, has no full dimension non-irrigated pitch wherever on this planet for testing simply but. Tencate Grass, the turf producer partnered to the Dutch NA, has 1 full dimension dry turf obtainable for testing. However to this point the participant’s reactions are that it will be not possible to play our recreation on it with out making large sacrifices.
For the 2026 World Cup to be performed on dry turf, the FIH would must be taking part in all of their Professional League video games on a dry turf beginning on the 2024-2025 season on the newest. Not very possible with out the sport altering considerably.
Nonetheless each candidates for the EHF presidency state they’re OK with adjustments to our sport for this to occur earlier than the 2026 world cup. Neither of them nonetheless goes into element a lot about what can be acceptable and what not. Nor did the president and CEO of FIH after I requested them the identical query in a press meet over the past Professional League. All sports activities directors appear to agree if they’re versatile of their deadline for this the R&D departments, these will decelerate. In my eyes a shortsighted perspective by them.
Will we adapt to new circumstances? Certain, people all the time do. However our sport would be the poorer for it!
What concerning the EHL?
As a substitute of taking away from the game, the EHL has introduced us many enhancements. The self-pass rule to call however one… However will it have a future? Its threats are the complete worldwide calendar and lowering monetary help from sponsors.
Elders agrees with the monetary risk. However the answer to the monetary stress to this point is similar as to the dry turf coming our approach… Simply reside with it and adapt.
It’s all the time a tense relation. The instances of , give me your cash and I’ll determine what to do with it are over. In order that’s the brand new life…
Peter Elders
Hoffman elaborates a bit extra… however has no actual reply right now both.
Currently the EHL gasoline form of been stagnating. That’s the reason there was an try to revamp the competitors. To alter the format, to usher in new capital.
Marcos Hofmann
Hofmann continues he observed there have been two opinions. One to stretch the format and hold a spherical in October and Easter. One other to have it extra concentrated and solely at Easter. Possibly for extra days than simply the extended Easter weekend. Have some further occasions round the principle one like extra youth or masters occasions on the identical time and site. To pay attention sources and avoid wasting cash that option to hold it going. However to make that alternative there must be some extra time to have actual enterprise pushed talks about this as an alternative of talks alongside the hockey discipline.
Why select you for the following EHF president?
The ultimate query for each was to explain why they need to be the following president for the EHF. As a substitute of me sharing my opinions right here I believed it will be extra truthful to the each of them to allow them to do the speaking with out my opinionated sauce on high of it. And it’d even be higher to not restrict it to their reply to this particular query. Hear (watch) the complete dialog above or as a podcast on Spotify or the common podcast channels.
So there you go… by the point the European Championship may have began we’ll know who was chosen by the European nationwide associations to be their subsequent president. Whoever it will likely be they are going to have some severe challenges forward of them defending the European methods within the FIH to call however one.