The Chewsday Chew – Shorts & Sweets (Ep5-24)

Gudday Cobbers. Once more, right here’s the standard reminder that we’re a fan-run volunteer website and all are welcome to make a contribution. You possibly can e-mail me straight if you want at or you should use this LINK from the homepage to provide us your contribution. We genuinely welcome it as recent voices and views are so invaluable to our recreation.

I’m a bit pushed for time this week, so I’ll make it quick(ish) and candy(ish):

Go the mighty Wauchope Thunder!

Nutta’s Aussie Rugby Crew of the Week:

So long as you performed for an Aussie facet this weekend gone, you will get picked.

  1. Angus Bell – was out-scrummed early however bought stronger because the minutes grew.
  2. Mahe Vailanu – threw nicely and an enormous across the floor effort.
  3. Taniela Tupou – nonetheless essentially the most damaging TH now we have.
  4. Jed Holloway – my MotM v Crusaders. Graft and craft.
  5. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto – had an enormous 1st half particularly.
  6. Rob Leota – performed a powerhouse recreation and right here’s hoping it’s his new customary.
  7. Charlie Gamble – better of the Aussie no7s throughout the weekend.
  8. Harry Wilson – route one all day with real effort and creativity.
  9. Jake Gordon – nice effort and management to convey his facet dwelling.
  10. Carter Gordon – pleasing creativity with none mind explosions.
  11. Corey Toole – hopefully Schmidty retains his quantity.
  12. Joey Walton – ran some very nice traces.
  13. Josh Flook – nice D and a unbelievable ‘consciousness’ pie. A ‘fronties’ centre.
  14. Harry Potter – magic.
  15. Andrew Kellaway – simply squeezed out Max Jorgensen for mine.
  16. Tom Horton – his throwing was sound and his support-play first charge.
  17. Matt Gibbon – actually strong and continues to push for larger honours.
  18. Harry Johnson-Holmes – a genuinely gutsy effort.
  19. Jeremy Williams – nice defensive lineout work in-particular.
  20. Liam Wright – a correct inglorious bastard. I’m growing a man-crush.
  21. Tate McDermott – busy and a fast palms strive.
  22. Noah Lolesio – a really composed recreation with try-saving defence thrown in.
  23. Max Burey – did the little issues nicely and jagged a pie.
Cooma is ‘bracing and salubrious’ so I’ve been informed

Different participant chat/observations from the weekend:

  • Peni Ravai performed his coronary heart out for the Reds, particularly within the scrum. You can truly see him trembling beneath the stress at occasions. However his palms failed him, and the Reds, at two essential moments. So Gibbo bought the jersey once more this week. And talking of dangerous palms, Langi Gleeson…
  • Ryan Smith together with Hugh Sinclair deserve honourable mentions for enormous effort video games within the Locks. These have been dead-set trustworthy shifts. And for Hugh it was second week operating he was unfortunate to overlook out.
  • An enormous thumbs as much as Kiwi sides for maintaining the ACT and Qld loose-forwards comparatively contained. Our No7s particularly have been comparatively quiet this weekend versus their regular performances, and quite a lot of that was high quality opposition.
  • How bodily have been the Hurricanes? They genuinely introduced the ache as carry-on baggage and it was (begrudgingly) grand to see. Think about if one Ardie Savea was nonetheless charging about with them reasonably than with Kumbaya Dave at Kobe Kobelco Steelers in Japan?
  • As for the Crusaders, they’re nothing if not a primary charge manufacturing facility for brand spanking new gamers. Okay, they’ve had an extraordinary begin this 12 months. However these writing them off fail to heed the lesson the Cru so usually train: they produce high quality cattle. Their time will come return.
  • I believed all our Aussie 10s performed fairly nicely over the weekend. I nonetheless suppose that Noah is the decide of the bunch. However Flash performed nicely (therefore his choice) as did Lynagh. Ducky Donaldson, whereas not dangerous per se, continues to be hit or miss for me (an excessive amount of miss) which most likely explains why Cron has a revolving door with him and Max Burey in rotation.
  • Talking of 10s, the Stan commentary crew gave effusing accolades to Tane Edmed, to the purpose I discovered it much more cringey than SBW speaking about rolling rucks. And I didn’t suppose Edmed performed that particularly nicely. Poor defensive reads by him led to 2 of the Cru tries. And a poor kick-pass wasted a comparatively easy Marky Marky strive alternative in an in any other case open backfield. Now Tahs followers, don’t get me mistaken, Tane definitely didn’t suck. However the heapings of reward felt a bit over-done to the purpose it was nearly contrived to make the child cry once more.
  • How the hell was the Chiefs reserve prop head-on-head effort on Brumby’s Cadeyrn Neville not a straight-up purple card (see beneath)? Yeh, Yeh, it was adjudged a yellow X (cheesey evaluate) that was certainly upgraded. However severely, in what universe was that shot not an outright shiraz? What within the good Lord’s title wanted to be reviewed apart from it was simply one other traditional little bit of play from a Kiwi prop named Joe Moody, Owen Franks, Ofa Tuʻungafasi, Richard Loe Jared Proffit?

And whereas on that match’s officiating James Doleman deserves extra point out, notably his fifteenth minute short-arm on Ryan Lonergan for time losing at a ruck base whereas positioning for a box-kick. For it was simply poor type. Sure, I agree that caterpillar rucks are an eyesore on the sport and we should always encourage tempo over go-slow ways. No argument from me there. But when we’re critical about addressing such issues, then we have to do it correctly. And that entails something however the completely random utility of a rogue legislation interpretation in an unexpected and uncommunicated method.

Firstly, I might humbly level out that our present world champions South Africa, as topped lower than six months in the past, utilise that very sin and have honed it to the purpose of artwork type. So for it to be now deemed worthy of short-arming is a outstanding reversal of opinion. Secondly, it’s a tactic we see gainfully employed by each nationwide facet world over. Thirdly, that very same tactic is then seen in close to each premier competitors all around the world as nicely. And fourth, whereas I began to depend what number of of them we noticed within the opening two rounds of Tremendous Rugby, I ended counting at 50 occasions.

My level is that the difficulty is prolific and permeates the sport. It’s coached, game-managed and deliberate for accordingly. So if we now need to change the behaviour, in any other case valued and rewarded prior to now, by making use of Regulation 9.7.d in a fashion that hitherto has not been seen, then it must be appropriately and proactively communicated. Not simply randomly pulled out of some ref’s arse again pocket. Meaning, amongst different issues:

  • Having the change in interpretation communicated and highlighted within the weekly pre-game chat from Tremendous Rugby HQ to the groups,
  • Having the change highlighted once more within the pre-match ref/captains’ coin-toss and briefings within the tunnel,
  • Even perhaps warning about it early within the match to make sure,

However to only indiscriminately pull a Mathieu Raynal Particular in any respect, however then use it to present an opposition possession and subject place in such a profound method, is exceedingly poor. It’s so poor it truly denigrates the place of the referee. And that’s earlier than I level out the apparent that Dolly Doleman’s one-off solo man effort in match 5 of spherical 2 of Tremendous Rugby now paints ALL tremendous refs into the identical nook of getting to use that very same interpretation constantly and constantly throughout ALL tremendous matches any more, or having it turn into the poster-boy cliche of inept ‘coverage on the run’ game-mismanagement it was.

Chapter 1 of Recreation Administration 101

And eventually for this week, it was nice to see sanity prevail with the powers that be truly studying my article final Tuesday and altering their strategy with regards the ‘good’ mouthguards. For those who missed it the place final week a excessive rating on the kinetic-force-measuring, blue-toothed enabled mouthguard triggered an automated elimination of a participant from the sector for a evaluate, this week such an alert as a substitute triggered an on-field evaluation by a suitably certified human to evaluate if the participant does in reality should be eliminated for additional evaluation. It’s a smart change that leaves people in command of a human scenario. Good work to all concerned. Naturally, I take all of the credit score.

Luv youse all. Remark away beneath.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *